My cats are not particularly fussy but they won't go near the one with fish and rice. It looks very unappetising, kind of like a sticky mush. The rest is ok, but they're definitely not my cats' favourite. I only gave 3 stars because it's meant to be healthier for them as it's organic.
Bought this because of the organic ingredients. My cats aren't fond of pate-looking food. It did have a little jelly which you can scrape from the bottom of the pouch to make it more interesting for my cats. They did eat it, don't get me wrong and I am sure it did them the world of good, however if you want something that has texture, then this is not the one.