The squeak and flashing eyes make this a winner
Ordered this along with some other more expensive toys, the day I adopted Precious. This is the favourite so far. She loves swatting it and running after round the room with it. I am watching her just now and she even pretends to stalk it. She looks so cute and a little bit ferocious.
Only downside, is you are not able to leave your cat unsupervised with it. I actually don't mind this as I like that I get to watch the fun.
So maybe it should be 5 stars.