These treats are fantastic, all my cats love them and its great that they are just chicken, nothing else added but I have found that you end up with lots of powder in the bottom, which I usually just pour over their food but I would prefer to be able to serve the entire tube properly. I've recently moved over to Orijen treats and the cats also adore them just as much, they seem a bit pricier than thrive on the surface but since you can use the entire packet, I think it works out similarly.