Shame - size varies too much even though good
My medium sized dog used to love this - until the third pack. The first two were just perfect for him and I thought I had found our dream treat to keep him occupied for a long time! But those from the third order were too big and my dog was frustrated as he couldn't tackle it. I bought three packs and was left with most of them untouched. Although I stopped buying this I would still give a four star as it should be an issue for large dogs. I didn't mind the smell as long as he could eat it.