I am writing about the poultry flavour as there are already a few for the beef version. I have 3 dogs who must be the fussiest dogs out. I have tried most makes of food wet and dry. They either flatly ignore it or will eat it for a while, then refuse. Frolic is the only make they will all eat although sadly it is not the healthiest. They enjoy it which is the main thing. I would have preferred to use it just as a treat or training aid. 4 stars as it's not particularly healthy choice.