I still can't find my perfect scoop. The holes are too large allowing the litter and smaller lumps to pass through. However, it collects most of the dump, but it gets stuck to the scoop very easily.
Just about does the job
I use clumping litter, but I think I would prefer a finer mesh on my scooper. This one can allow litter to fall through the holes from box to bin bag. But at the price, I can live with it!