Good - sometimes
Only treats that last our smallish bully mix any length of time BUT sizes are inconsistent. First batch was great, long pieces we could safely give for a while and remove when too small (he tries to swallow chews & regularly starts choking). We ordered 3 more bags, but our last order was full of small bits (about a third very small), about 1/4 of the size of the first ones. They last no time and are a lot more dangerous. I understand they're a natural product, but size grading would be helpful.